Barrow Logo Barrow EP Handbook

Underground storage tank removed with no closure report

An underground storage tank (UST) was taken out of the ground at the subject property, and no closure report or sampling result shows what the excavation held. The missing report is the absence of a record, and the standard cautions that records are often wrong or incomplete (E1527-21, 8.1.3). Whether a recognized environmental condition (REC) goes with the former tank depends on four things: when the tank was closed and whether the federal tank rule reached it, whether anything points to a release, what the tank was and how long it served, and who may still hold the closure record.

What the answer turns on

Unless a release is documented or known, the question is likely presence owing to a release or a likely release, the second part of the REC definition (E1527-21, 3.2.73). The standard's appendixes are nonmandatory. The federal tank rule, 40 CFR part 280, says what closing a covered tank involves and who keeps the results; it classifies nothing under the standard.

  • When the tank was closed, and whether the rule reached it. Under part 280 a tank taken out of service for good is emptied and cleaned, then removed, filled with an inert solid, or closed in place as the implementing agency approves (40 CFR 280.71(b)). Before the closure is complete, owners and operators measure for a release at the place where contamination is most likely; operating vapor or groundwater monitoring that shows none satisfies it (40 CFR 280.72(a)). For a system closed for good before December 22, 1988, the rule calls for an assessment when the implementing agency, judging that releases may pose a threat, directs one (40 CFR 280.73). Without that direction, a closure that old may never have had one. The rule's UST definition also leaves some tanks out, such as a heating oil tank whose oil is burned on the premises (40 CFR 280.12).
  • Whether anything points to a release. Appendix X4's examples of direct evidence include a UST closure inspection form that records an observed leak, and a key site manager with actual knowledge that a tank taken out of the subject property had been leaking (E1527-21, X4.1). Under part 280, contamination found at closure starts corrective action (40 CFR 280.72(b)), so check the leaking tank (LUST) list. Migration of petroleum products includes vapor in the subsurface (E1527-21, 3.2.53).
  • What the tank was, and how long it served. A UST system includes its connected underground piping (40 CFR 280.12). Appendix X4's note gives a bare steel UST installed decades ago with no leak detection as a possible example of a likely release, if the environmental professional believes one has likely occurred (E1527-21, X4.1).
  • Who may hold the closure record. Unless a permanent closure is in response to corrective action, owners and operators notify the agency at least 30 days ahead, or within another period it sets (40 CFR 280.71(a)), so its file may hold a notice and no results. The results of the assessment are kept by the owners and operators who closed the system, by the site's current owners and operators, or "By mailing these records to the implementing agency if they cannot be maintained at the closed facility" (40 CFR 280.74). At least three years after closure is the only period that section sets, so the closure's age bears on whether a report can still be expected.

The records that bear on it

  • The registration and the agency file. Registered tank lists are a standard source, searched for the subject property and adjoining properties (registered storage tanks; E1527-21, 8.2.2, Table 2). For a listed subject property the file should be reviewed, or the report explains why not; the report gives the professional's opinion on whether what was reviewed is enough (E1527-21, 8.2.3.1, 8.2.3.2).
  • Other sources. For a subject property on a list, other sources may stand in for the agency's file: on-site records, records the user provides, local government records, interviews with officials and others who know the matter (E1527-21, 8.2.3.2). A removed tank may be on no list: part 280's notice duty covered systems in the ground on May 8, 1986 or later, unless out of operation by January 1, 1974 or already notified under CERCLA (40 CFR 280.22(a)). The route is then the standard's other means, such as questions to the current owner or occupants, and the interviews (E1527-21, 8.1.7).
  • Documents and interviews. The owner, key site manager and user are asked whether they know of tank registrations, site investigation reports and cleanup reports (E1527-21, 10.8, 10.8.1). Past owners and operators likely to have material information are interviewed where identified (E1527-21, 10.5.4).
  • Site visit. Vent pipes, fill pipes and access ways are looked for (E1527-21, 9.4.12).

What the federal rule says

The tank rule says:

Before permanent closure or a change-in-service is completed, owners and operators must measure for the presence of a release where contamination is most likely to be present at the UST site.

40 CFR 280.72(a), edition revised as of July 1, 2025

The inquiry rule, 40 CFR part 312, lists among the records for the subject property

storage tank records and permits

40 CFR 312.26(b)(2), edition revised as of July 1, 2025

For a party seeking the liability protections that rule's subject is hazardous substances (40 CFR 312.1(c)(1)); the standard includes petroleum products (E1527-21, 1.1.2).

How it is written up

A tank that once stood at the subject property is past storage, which the report describes (E1527-21, 9.4, 9.4.2). It becomes a finding when the professional judges it may indicate presence or likely presence at the subject property, and the opinion reasons for or against calling it a REC (E1527-21, 12.5, 12.6).

Where the professional concludes a release occurred or is likely, the opinion gives the grounds: the tank, its years of service, what the file and the interviews hold. Unless judged a de minimis condition or a historical REC, the REC is listed in the Conclusions, and the professional should give an opinion on additional investigation, if any (E1527-21, 3.2.20, 3.2.39, 12.7, 12.8).

Where the professional concludes otherwise, the opinion gives its reasoning on the same four facts (E1527-21, 12.6). Whether the closure met the tank rule is regulatory compliance, outside the standard's scope unless the user adds it (E1527-21, 13.1.2, 13.1.5.14).

The interview with the key site manager, or with a regulatory official, may be what could not be held. Required information that good faith efforts could not obtain is a data gap, significant if it affects the ability to identify a REC: named in the Findings with the sources consulted, discussed in the Opinions and listed in the Conclusions (E1527-21, 3.2.19, 3.2.78, 12.5.1, 12.6.2, 12.7).

Related

This page is general reference for environmental professionals. It does not classify any property. ASTM E1527-21 is the standard and is not reproduced here; the judgment of the environmental professional on the facts governs.

Maintained by Barrow. General reference only, not legal or professional advice. Barrow is not affiliated with any government agency, and neither Barrow nor the information as presented here is endorsed by any state or government agency. See how Barrow drafts the report